Home Page Link Thaxted - under the present flightpath and threatened with quadrupled activity Takeley's 12th century parish church, close to proposed second runway Harcamlow Way, Bamber's Green - much of the long distance path and village would disappear under Runway 2 Clavering - typical of the Uttlesford villages threatened by urbanisation
Campaigning against proposals to expand Stansted Airport

image Press Release - 31 January 2008


In a further sign that BAA cannot make up its mind on the viability of a second runway at Stansted, the airport operator has warned its economic regulator the CAA of the need for a price settlement which delivers investment in new runway capacity. (Note 1) The clear implication is that BAA won't build a new runway at Stansted unless the CAA allows a dramatic increase in the prices BAA is allowed to charge airlines and passengers.

In 2006 BAA told the CAA that a second Stansted runway was not commercially viable because it would not generate a sufficient rate of return even to cover its cost of capital. (Note 2) Since then BAA had been pinning its hopes on having Stansted removed from the regulatory framework so that it could raise airport charges to justify the cost of a second runway. However, Transport Secretary Ruth Kelly vetoed that proposal earlier this month. (Note 3)

Stop Stansted Expansion (SSE) Economics Adviser Brian Ross commented: "From our point of view there is nothing new or surprising in this latest statement from BAA but it completely contradicts the message coming from BAA management at Stansted, namely that 'BAA is absolutely committed to the G2 project'." (Note 4)

Mr Ross continued "Either BAA is trying to bluff the CAA or it is not 'absolutely committed' to a second runway."

It is not only the CAA who are receiving this ambivalent message from BAA. The airport operator has also been assuring its lenders that its investment plans represent 'an option to build, not a commitment to build.' (Note 5)

BAA has a debt mountain of over 12 billion, and its Spanish parent company, Ferrovial, has net debt of 23.4 billion. Ferrovial's share price has halved over the past nine months and its debt is now a staggering 5.2 times the market value of the business. (Note 6)

Mr Ross concluded "This latest statement from BAA is the clearest evidence yet that its resolve to build a second runway at Stansted is faltering and, given all the circumstances, we do not find that at all surprising."

BAA is expected to submit its much-delayed planning application for a second runway at Stansted in March. SSE views this as a speculative exercise rather than a genuine signal of BAA's intent.


1. See BAA's formal response to the CAA's consultation on prices at Stansted, issued on 25 January 2008 and available on BAA website at www.baa.com/portal/page/Corporate%5EMedia+Centre%5ENews+releases

2. Source: 'Airports Price Control Review: Initial Proposals for Heathrow, Gatwick and Stansted', CAA, Dec 2006 www.caa.co.uk/docs/5/ergdocs/airportsdec06/section4.pdf.  Para 21.16 states: "BAA did not provide a view as to the future cost of capital at Stansted in its September 2006 regulatory submission, instead pointing out that its assumptions about the opening date and price resulted in a rate of return of just over 8% pre-tax real over Q5 and Q6. However, BAA subsequently wrote to the CAA indicating that in its current view the cost of capital at Stansted (on a pre-tax, real basis) was 8.79%."

3. Announcement by Secretary of State for Transport on 15 January 2008. See Department for Transport website: www.dft.gov.uk.

4. For example BAA Stansted Bulletin 30 November 2007. Copy available from SSE upon request.

5. BAA 'Debt Roadshow' Slide Presentation, 2006. Copy available from SSE on request.

6. Latest published financial accounts for Grupo Ferrovial SA can be found on Ferrovial's website at www.ferrovial.com/en/index.asp?MP=16&MS=284&MN=2 and show 31.1bn net debt (23.4). Ferrovial's current market capitalisation is 5.9bn (4.5bn) BAA/ADI's latest published accounts can be obtained from Companies House or from SSE upon request.

Carol Barbone, Campaign Director, SSE: M 0777 552 3091, cbarbone@mxc.co.uk

Media Centre